Why the Sarrus Rule Stops at Order Three: A Mathematical Explanation and Its Teaching Implications
Journal: Journal of Higher Education Research DOI: 10.32629/jher.v7i2.5152
Abstract
The Sarrus rule (or diagonal rule) is how most students first learn to calculate 2×2 and 3×3 determinants. It's simple, visual, and widely taught. Yet many assume it extends to 4×4 or larger determinants — and run into trouble. This paper explains why the rule necessarily stops at orders n=3. The explanation draws on three perspectives. First, a combinatorial count: for n ≥ 4, the n! terms of the determinant cannot be captured by the 2n terms of any diagonal‑type rule. Second, permutation groups: showing that the Sarrus rule captures only two specific subsets of the symmetric group Sn — a complete coverage for S3 but a severe underrepresentation for n ≥ 4. Third, Laplace expansion: the compact form of the rule for n=3 is a special case of the cofactor expansion that has no analogue in higher dimensions. These findings suggest a natural teaching sequence. Students practice the rule on low‑order examples, then try it on a 4×4 matrix where it fails. That failure opens the door to the formal definition and, finally, to general methods. This approach transforms a common student misconception into a foundation for understanding the structure of determinants.
Full Text
PDF - Viewed/Downloaded: 0 TimesReferences
[1] Lorenz, D, Wirths, K. J. (2018). Sarrus rules for matrix determinants and dihedral groups. The College Mathematics Journal, 49(5), 333-340.
[2] Mitrinović, D, Mihajlović, D, Ulčar, J. (1960). Zbornik matematičkih problema sa prilozima i numeričkim tablicama II. Beograd: Naučna Knjiga.
[3] Bankier, J. D. (1961). The diagrammatic expansion of determinants. The American Mathematical Monthly, 68(8), 788-790.
[4] Sobamowo, M. G. (2016). On the extension of Sarrus‘ rule to n×n (n>3) matrices: Development of new method for the computation of the determinant of 4×4 matrix. International Journal of Engineering Mathematics, 2016, 9382739.
[5] Salinas-Hernández, E, et al. (2021). Sarrus rule extension for 4×4 and 5×5 determinants. International Journal of Algebra, 15(4), 283-301.
[6] Zhuo Muxiang. (2020). Diagonal expansion method of fourth order determinant based on algebraic cofactor. Mathematical Learning and Research, (1), 10-11.
[7] Zeng Zhenbing, Huang Yong, Rao Yongsheng. (2020). Discuss determinant teaching from the angle of educational mathematics. Advanced Mathematical Studies, 23(4), 10-21.
[8] Yang Yuping, Song Keyan. (2021). The teaching difficulty and solution of determinant expansion theorem in linear algebra. Journal of Southwest Normal University (Natural Science Edition), 46(6), 190-194.
[9] Arschon, S. (1935). Verallgemeinerte Sarrussche Regel [Generalized Sarrus rule]. Matematicheskii Sbornik, 42(1), 121-128.
[2] Mitrinović, D, Mihajlović, D, Ulčar, J. (1960). Zbornik matematičkih problema sa prilozima i numeričkim tablicama II. Beograd: Naučna Knjiga.
[3] Bankier, J. D. (1961). The diagrammatic expansion of determinants. The American Mathematical Monthly, 68(8), 788-790.
[4] Sobamowo, M. G. (2016). On the extension of Sarrus‘ rule to n×n (n>3) matrices: Development of new method for the computation of the determinant of 4×4 matrix. International Journal of Engineering Mathematics, 2016, 9382739.
[5] Salinas-Hernández, E, et al. (2021). Sarrus rule extension for 4×4 and 5×5 determinants. International Journal of Algebra, 15(4), 283-301.
[6] Zhuo Muxiang. (2020). Diagonal expansion method of fourth order determinant based on algebraic cofactor. Mathematical Learning and Research, (1), 10-11.
[7] Zeng Zhenbing, Huang Yong, Rao Yongsheng. (2020). Discuss determinant teaching from the angle of educational mathematics. Advanced Mathematical Studies, 23(4), 10-21.
[8] Yang Yuping, Song Keyan. (2021). The teaching difficulty and solution of determinant expansion theorem in linear algebra. Journal of Southwest Normal University (Natural Science Edition), 46(6), 190-194.
[9] Arschon, S. (1935). Verallgemeinerte Sarrussche Regel [Generalized Sarrus rule]. Matematicheskii Sbornik, 42(1), 121-128.
Copyright © 2026 Qinqin Wan, Chuan Shi
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License